Overview

Arlene Fickler has spent decades defending businesses in complex, high-stakes litigation, from nationwide class actions to disputes involving novel questions of law. With a keen understanding of the financial and operational consequences of litigation, she works to protect her clients’ interests while pursuing resolutions that make sound business sense.

Arlene Fickler represents businesses in complex commercial litigation, class action defense, and other significant disputes. Her experience spans products liability, toxic torts, securities fraud, antitrust, and matters involving emerging legal issues. Clients turn to Arlene when the stakes are high, the legal questions are complicated, or a dispute threatens to become disproportionately expensive. She evaluates each matter with an eye toward limiting exposure, controlling costs and achieving a resolution that serves the client’s broader business interests, whether through litigation or settlement.

Arlene’s approach reflects both her intellectual curiosity and her appreciation for the businesses and industries at the center of each dispute. She takes particular interest in developing persuasive legal arguments, drawing on decades of experience to identify the issues most likely to influence the outcome and present her client’s position effectively. Her work has taken her from defending manufacturers in nationwide products liability class actions to representing hedge funds in defamation actions and litigating precedent-setting questions involving anonymous online speech. While the subject matter varies considerably, her objective remains consistent: understand the client’s business, assess the risks, and find the most effective way to resolve the problem without unnecessary expense or disruption. 

The relationships Arlene develops with clients often extend well beyond a particular lawsuit. For nearly three decades, she has advised the U.S. subsidiary of a German manufacturer, beginning with its establishment in Philadelphia and continuing through its current expansion into new facilities. That long-standing relationship reflects her willingness to serve as a trusted resource on matters that extend beyond her litigation practice, including contractual, employment and operational questions.

Equally committed to the legal profession and her community, Arlene has held leadership roles with the University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law, Penn’s Law Alumni Society, the Philadelphia Bar Association, the University of Pennsylvania American Inn of Court, and numerous community service and charitable organizations. She is a former chair of the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Philadelphia and serves on the board of the Jewish Council for Public Affairs, reflecting her longstanding commitment to building bridges among different communities of faith and ethnicity in pursuit of a more just and democratic society for all. Additionally, Arlene’s experience in defending class actions led to her serving as a co-reporter for the Manual on Mass Tort Litigation published by the American College of Trial Lawyers.

Representative Experience

  • Represented a building products manufacturer in approximately two dozen class actions involving claims of deteriorating roofing shingles. Negotiated a claims-made settlement that modestly increased warranty payments for qualifying property owners while providing a framework for resolving the claims.
  • Defended manufacturers in asbestos-related property damage class actions brought on behalf of schools, colleges, universities, federal building lessors, and hospitals. In one matter, successfully prevented a major insurance company from pursuing an individual federal lawsuit seeking more than $110 million in asbestos abatement costs because it had failed to opt out of a previously settled class action.
  • Advised a manufacturer of swimming pool chemicals in resolving class action claims arising from a plant fire that prompted the evacuation of a surrounding neighborhood.
  • Negotiated a claims-made settlement for a cement plant operator facing class action claims by local residents seeking damages for personal injury and property damage, medical monitoring and injunctive relief related to plant emissions.
  • Negotiated a claims-made settlement on behalf of a chemical manufacturer in a community-wide toxic tort class action involving allegations of chemical emissions during manufacturing operations.
  • Served as special asbestos counsel in the Chapter 11 reorganization of a manufacturer of asbestos-containing products, including acting as trial counsel during the asbestos phase of the plan confirmation hearing.
  • Served as court-appointed counsel to a receiver pursuing recovery of investor losses arising from a Ponzi scheme. The receiver’s efforts resulted in claimants recovering at least 31% of their investments.
  • Represented nonmanagement directors of a supermarket chain in securities fraud litigation when it was discovered that the principal of a deep discount drugstore chain, which was substantially owned by the supermarket chain, had engaged in accounting fraud. 
  • Represented an entity responsible for coordinating electricity transmission across the interstate power grid in a personal injury lawsuit brought by an employee of a member transmission company. Secured an appellate ruling recognizing the entity’s immunity from liability under its federally approved tariff.
  • Represented several hedge funds facing defamation claims arising from short-selling activities and published reports and internet posts questioning the market valuations of publicly traded companies.
  • Represented an anonymous internet poster in a precedent-setting California appellate case establishing the standard for when an anonymous online speaker’s identity may be disclosed.
  • Represented the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board in litigation concerning the implementation of Pennsylvania’s gaming legislation and the location of gaming facilities. Obtained relief from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court preventing a proposed Philadelphia ballot question that conflicted with the state gaming law.
  • Represented the American Jewish Congress and the National Jewish Community Relations Advisory Council in County of Allegheny v. ACLU, the United States Supreme Court case involving the display of a crèche and Menorah on public property.

Professional Recognition

  • The Best Lawyers in America, Commercial Litigation, 2012-present; Appellate Practice, 2026-present
  • Martindale-Hubbell, AV Preeminent
  • Pennsylvania Super Lawyers, 2004-2006
  • Jewish Social Policy Action Network, Social Justice Award, 2010
  • University of Pennsylvania Law School, Alumni Award of Merit, 2001
  • Jewish Community Centers Association of North America, Esther Leah Ritz Next Generation Leadership Award, 2000
  • Philadelphia Jewish Federation, Mrs. Isidore Kohn Young Leadership Award, 1981

Professional & Community Activities

  • University of Pennsylvania’s Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law, Executive Board Member
  • University of Pennsylvania Law School American Inn of Court, Member and Secretary
  • University of Pennsylvania Law Alumni Society, member of Board of Managers and past President
  • American Law Institute, Life Member
  • Philadelphia Bar Association, Member; Seasoned Lawyers Committee, Co-Chair; Federal Courts Committee, past Chair; Judicial Commission, Investigative Team Member
  • American Bar Association, Member
  • Pennsylvania Bar Association, Member
  • Jewish Center for Public Affairs, Director and Governance Committee Chair
  • Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Philadelphia, Leadership Committee Member and past Chair
  • Jewish Cemeteries Association of Philadelphia, Co-Founder and Director
  • Jewish Community Centers of Greater Philadelphia, past Chair
  • HIAS Pennsylvania, Ambassador and past Treasurer
  • Temple Beth Zion-Beth Israel, past President

Representative Experience

  • Represented a building products manufacturer in approximately two dozen class actions involving claims of deteriorating roofing shingles. Negotiated a claims-made settlement that modestly increased warranty payments for qualifying property owners while providing a framework for resolving the claims.
  • Defended manufacturers in asbestos-related property damage class actions brought on behalf of schools, colleges, universities, federal building lessors, and hospitals. In one matter, successfully prevented a major insurance company from pursuing an individual federal lawsuit seeking more than $110 million in asbestos abatement costs because it had failed to opt out of a previously settled class action.
  • Advised a manufacturer of swimming pool chemicals in resolving class action claims arising from a plant fire that prompted the evacuation of a surrounding neighborhood.
  • Negotiated a claims-made settlement for a cement plant operator facing class action claims by local residents seeking damages for personal injury and property damage, medical monitoring and injunctive relief related to plant emissions.
  • Negotiated a claims-made settlement on behalf of a chemical manufacturer in a community-wide toxic tort class action involving allegations of chemical emissions during manufacturing operations.
  • Served as special asbestos counsel in the Chapter 11 reorganization of a manufacturer of asbestos-containing products, including acting as trial counsel during the asbestos phase of the plan confirmation hearing.
  • Served as court-appointed counsel to a receiver pursuing recovery of investor losses arising from a Ponzi scheme. The receiver’s efforts resulted in claimants recovering at least 31% of their investments.
  • Represented nonmanagement directors of a supermarket chain in securities fraud litigation when it was discovered that the principal of a deep discount drugstore chain, which was substantially owned by the supermarket chain, had engaged in accounting fraud. 
  • Represented an entity responsible for coordinating electricity transmission across the interstate power grid in a personal injury lawsuit brought by an employee of a member transmission company. Secured an appellate ruling recognizing the entity’s immunity from liability under its federally approved tariff.
  • Represented several hedge funds facing defamation claims arising from short-selling activities and published reports and internet posts questioning the market valuations of publicly traded companies.
  • Represented an anonymous internet poster in a precedent-setting California appellate case establishing the standard for when an anonymous online speaker’s identity may be disclosed.
  • Represented the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board in litigation concerning the implementation of Pennsylvania’s gaming legislation and the location of gaming facilities. Obtained relief from the Pennsylvania Supreme Court preventing a proposed Philadelphia ballot question that conflicted with the state gaming law.
  • Represented the American Jewish Congress and the National Jewish Community Relations Advisory Council in County of Allegheny v. ACLU, the United States Supreme Court case involving the display of a crèche and Menorah on public property.